Stocking help? I've been getting mixed answers...?

Sorry, none of your selections are good. Every tank needs an alge eater. (common alge eater) I would recemend 3-4 platties, no guppies the tend to be a little more difficult to take care of in a new tank but after you've had the platties and alge eater in there a while then you could add them. After that you can add a wide variety of fish,no gold fish they will make your tank dirty. i would add a few neon tetras. Also any other type of tetra is good because they are all small.